Tag Archives: Reflections

An app-ortunity

Quite reasonably I have been asked how an NHS ePortfolio app would benefit doctors, and what it would have to do to be worth any investment. In my opinion the need for an app is driven by the need to make WPBAs more relevant. An app would put control back in the hands of trainees, and make life significantly easier for trainers/assessors. This would reduce resentment towards WBPAs and would save an unimaginably huge amount of time for a stressed, squeezed, overworked profession.

The current situation:

I am doctor in training (this covers everyone who is not yet a Consultant/GP partner). I am required to complete a certain number of WPBAs to progress. One day I am at work and am on call admitting new patients to hospital. I think I’ve made a pretty thorough assessment of a patient with a condition I’ve not encountered before and ask my Consultant if, after presentation of the case on the post-take ward round they can fill in a mini-CEX. They say yes.

I present my case during the round and the Consultant provides some useful immediate feedback on my assessment, including a recommendation to read a recent review on the subject in an academic medical journal. However, the Consultant has another 7 patients to review after this and can’t stop to find a computer, login, wait for it to load up, access the NHS ePortfolio website, login and complete the assessment. “Send me a ticket” they say, with a genuine intent to complete is as soon as possible. My shift gets busier and after 13hours at work I go straight to bed when I get home. The next day i am very busy and forget to send the ticket via email. I remember when I get home but realise I don’t know the Consultant’s email address. It’s a weekend so I’m not in for another 2 days. I set a reminder with an alarm on my phone and on Monday the alarm prompts me to retrieve the email  from the hospital system and I send the ticket from the NHS ePortfolio site.

A week later the assessment has not been completed and I send a reminder. Three days after this I bump into the Consultant in the lunch queue and gently remind them about the mini-CEX. They make excuses, feel bad, and promise to do it ASAP.

A week after this the Consultant finally has some time for admin and discovers my reminder email in their inbox. They login and struggle to remember anything about the patient or the feedback they gave me. They have an overall impression of whether I’m any good or not and complete the assessment mainly based on this overall view, rather than the specifics of the case we discussed. I get an email to say that the assessment has been completed. At a later date I login and read the comments, which are brief, and get no educational benefit from the recording of the episode. I do however feel less stressed as that’s one less assessment to get ticked off. I can’t remember the author of the review recommended by the Consultant and never quite get round to searching for it.

A possible future situation:

One day I am at work and am on call admitting new patients to hospital. I think I’ve made a pretty thorough assessment of a patient with a condition I’ve not encountered before and ask my Consultant if, after presentation of the case on the post-take ward round they can fill in a mini-CEX. They say yes.

I present my case during the round and the Consultant provides some useful immediate feedback on my assessment. I get out my smartphone and login to the NHS ePortfolio app. I bring up the mini-CEX form and we complete it together adding comments based on the feedback the Consultant has just given, including the recommendation to read a recent review by author X in journal Y. There is a prompt to enter the Consultant’s email address so that they can validate the mini-CEX as an accurate representation of the assessment, and I input this as the Consultant dictates it. I save the form. The Consultant continues with the post-take ward round. I continue to admit new patients.

When I get home my phone picks up my wifi signal, and the ePortfolio app automatically synchs with my account so that the mini-CEX is uploaded. An email is sent to my Consultant and me to inform us of this new entry on my ePortfolio. I don’t have to waste time chasing up multiple assessments like this, so actually get round to looking up the review recommended by the Consultant, and learn something that will benefit my future patients.

It is essential that an NHS ePortfolio app:

  • is cross platform (iPhone, android etc)
  • can perform most functions offline with synching later with the main site. Most NHS hospitals have no wifi and poor phone sinal coverage. If an app required wifi it would be of no use to many, many, users

Another possible function would be to record reflection-in-action – essentially quick notes about things that happen that are particularly challenging, satisfying etc. There would then be scope to comment on this in the portfolio later (reflection-on-action).  Professionals must be reflective to learn and develop, but there is debate around the value of writing down these reflections. An app would at least make the process easier for those that wished to do this.

Oh, and of course ideally it would be free. But I’d pay £0.69 to make my life easier, wouldn’t you?

Make categories of reflection less restrictive

Most doctors are naturally reflective. There is good evidence that more reflective clinicians learn from their experience and progress and develop. In this world of evidence, the powers that be have decided you need to prove that you are reflecting by logging it into your ePortfolio. This is very frustrating for many people. But if we can’t change the rules (yet), then we should make the systems work for us to make this generating-of-evidence-of-reflection less painful.

Reflection is a broad concept, but this is not reflected (ha ha!) in the current ePortfolio.

Today I listened to a podcast on my way into work, read a news article about the assisted dying bill on my laptop, had a chat with a colleague over coffee about a patient with a rare diagnosis, and moaned to my mum on the phone about a rude and unprofessional colleague. All of this is reflection. But where could I log any of this in my ePortfolio?

We need open categories, and the ability to log URLs/web links and comment on them. This needs to be fast and easy.